As a new discipline, the cardiac surgery has a great development in the modern age, but still faces many problems and disputes. The emergence of the evidence-based medicine (EBM), which emphasizes the best evidence, and combines the doctor’s clinical experience to make the best judgment, gives the development of the cardiac surgery a new thinking. Four systematic reviews published in The Cochrane Library (Issue 3, 2004) have interprated the importance of EBM on how to resolve the actual problems in different field of the cardiac surgery.
目的 探究妇科投诉纠纷发生的状况及原因，以改进工作方式减少投诉现象。 方法 对2005年1月－2010年12月妇科门诊和病房发生的投诉及医患纠纷资料进行收集，并对其原因进行分类统计分析，提出相关应对措施。 结果 6年间门诊及病房共发生投诉41例，纠纷8例。其医务人员技术水平不到位、服务态度差、沟通缺乏，就医环境差、收费不合理、患者自身因素等是投诉纠纷发生的主要原因。 结论 妇科是纠纷易发科室，但只要采用有效的控制措施，就能减少甚至避免医患纠纷的发生，提高患者满意度。
ObjectiveTo provide references in the forensic identification of injury and cerebrovascular malformation involved death cases, and to reduce the relevant medical dispute by exploring the forensic pathological features, identification of medical dispute as well as relationship between injury and disease. MethodsWe collected 33 cases of cerebrovascular malformation from January 2006 to December 2014 in West China Center of Forensic Medicine, including details of cases, clinical medical record and forensic pathology examination, and then the cases were retrospectively analyzed. ResultsIn the 33 cases, the average age of the individuals was 37.4 years old, and the male/female ratio was 23/10. Nineteen patients (57.6%) died within 1 hour. Seventeen patients with mixed pathological type of cerebrovascular malformation dominated (51.5%). Medical dispute happened in 7 cases (21.1%), 4 of which were identified to be led by medical fault and 3 with no medical fault. Relationship between injury and disease was analyzed in 11 cases (33.3%), in which injury was identified to take full responsibility in 1 case, inductive cause of death in 9 cases, and no relationship between injury and death in 1 case. ConclusionComprehensive and systematic investigation of forensic pathology plays an important role in the proper settlement of medical disputes as well as the identification of cause of death and relationship between injury and disease.
Family members are crucial for medical disputes. From the psychology and social perspective, the paper analyzes a specific medical dispute case, and discusses the psychological care for (potential) " shidu” (loss of the only child) family. Based on the current social context, an early intervention suggestion is proposed, that is to provide the whole-process psychological intervention to the special patients’ families. The intervention includes: regular psychological evaluation and psychological support if necessary; providing disease knowledge and death education; providing continuous psychological care by the hospital and community; offerring more psychological care for " shidu” family by society.
Objective To identify and analyze all medical injury liability disputes lawsuits pertaining to inferior vena cava filters (IVCF) in “Lexis®China” database, the causes and outcomes of litigation of the cases were clarified with a view, and to provide suggestions for preventing potential medical patient dispute lawsuits and improving the clinical diagnosis and treatment level of doctors. Method The term “inferior vena cava filter” was searched in Lexis®China, and spanning from 2011-01-01 to 2022-12-31. Results A total of 221 cases of medical injury liability disputes were found, after screening and exclusion, a total of 179 relevant cases were included in this study for analysis. All first instance lawsuits were brought by patients against hospitals and had a high rate of compensation awarded (91.6%). Forty four cases were entered second instance litigation, and the proportion of maintaining the original judgment was high (68.2%). The main content involving the modification of the judgment was to increase the compensation amount (85.7%). In the 14 lawsuits related to the failure to place IVCF by the medical authority, the litigation points were all disputes arising from the hospital’s improper diagnosis and treatment of VTE patients, which led to the failure to place IVCF, with the highest proportion (92.3%) of improper diagnosis and treatment of pulmonary embolism (PE). For PE and deep vein thrombosis patients with clear indications for IVCF implantation but not placed, leading to litigation, the hospital bore different liability for compensation (18%–100%) depending on the fault factors of the hospital’s negligence in diagnosis and treatment. The hospital could also be held responsible for inadequate informed disclosure to affect patient judgment (23.1%). In 165 lawsuits related to the placement of IVCF, the vast majority of IVCF implants were for the diagnosis and treatment of VTE in patients (73.9%). However, such unplanned operations caused additional injuries and expenses to patients, and VTE occurred most frequently during hospitalization (76.2%). This type of embolism was most commonly secondary to fracture incision and fixation surgery (31.2%), and the average liability of hospitals for compensation varied due to different secondary factors. The occurrence of intraoperative and postoperative complications related to IVCF implantation could also lead to litigation (18.8%), and the proportion of dead patients in litigation was relatively high (32.3%). The most common complication leading to litigation was PE recurrence or exacerbation (22.5%), while intraoperative complications were vascular injury during interventional procedures (2/3). The overall trend of IVCF-related lawsuits reserves between 2011 and 2020 showed an overall upward trend, reaching a peak of 37 cases in 2020; the average amount of damages exceeded 100 000 yuan per case in 10 of the 12 years included in the statistics. Conclusions In China’s IVCF-related medical liability lawsuits, patients most often sue their doctors, who are often sued for failure to insert a filter due to untimely diagnosis and treatment of VTE, inadequate notification of informed consent for IVCF insertion, unplanned IVCF insertion due to the presence of VTE and IVCF-related complications, and the outcome is often unfavourable to the doctors. In addition, the number of IVCF related lawsuits and hospital compensation amounts have remained high in recent years.