Objective To learn the current status, publication standards, formats, and contents of medical advertisements published in journals in China, and to discuss the possibility of evidence-based evaluation and standards for advertisement publication. Methods We handsearched Issue One, 2008 of 222 core medical journals indexed by A Guide to the Core Journals of China (2004 version) and the most important databases to index top 20% academic journals to identify basic journal information and the content of their advertisements. The general and trade name of the drugs, and the advertisements and production license number of the drugs and devices were collected. We used EXCEL software for data input and SPSS 13.0 for statistical analyses. Results Two-hundred and eighteen journals were handsearched and evaluated. The other 4 journals were excluded because the print version could not be found. A total of 1,201 advertisements were published in 159 (72.9%) of the journals, with the average of 5.5 (range of 1-37) for each journal. Of the advertisements, 910 (75.8%) were related to medical drugs or devices, including 598 (49.8%) drug and 312 (26.0%) medical device advertisements. Most of them were published in clinical and special medical journals. There were 518 (86.6%) drug advertisements which had both advertisement license and production license number, but only 116 (36.1%) medical device advertisements stated the advertisement license and production license number. Conclusion The medical drug advertisements published in core medical journals in China lack sufficient publication standards, and medical device advertisements are even worse. We cannot conclude the efficacy, safety, and cost-effectiveness of advertisement production according to the current limited, unclear, and highly-commercialized advertisements.
Active medical device is a kind of medical device which is widely used. In order to realize the goal of high-quality development, product with high reliability is a necessary requirement for the domestic active medical device industry. By means of literature research, data collection, field research, materials comprehensive combing and analysis, this paper systematically analyzes and studies the current situations and the existing problems of reliability and evaluation from the dimensions of Chinese active medical device industry policy, enterprise situation and evaluation method. In addition, by considering the technical characteristics of reliability work, concrete suggestions for solving the problems are given from the directions of standard and guiding principle, so as to provide reference for active medical device industry to develop scientific and objective reliability technical standard system and guiding principle, which are in accord with the current characteristics of Chinese active medical device industry and supervision.
To design a new suit of instruments for meniscal suture with tondon, and then authenticate their feasibil ity and the therapeutic effect of the new technique. Methods Instruments were developed, including new ones and others which was improved according to the current instruments. From October 2005 to December 2006, 45 patients with meniscal injury were treated by meniscal suture with tendon. There were 29 males and 16 females, aged 17-40 years (mean 28 years). Injury was caused by sports in 33 cases, by traffic accident in 5 cases, by fall ing in 3 case and others in 4 cases. The disease course was 3 days to 6 months (mean 2 months). There were 23 cases accompanying with anterior cruciate l igament injury and 6 cases accompanying with posterior cruciate l igament injury. E-MRI showed 2 cases of degree II and 43 cases of degree III. Arthroscope showed that injury was at medial meniscus in 39 cases and at lateral meniscus in 6 cases. The pre-operationalLysholm score was 53.0 ± 10.3. Autogeneic or xenogenic tendon was made into suture l ine guided by stitch at the two ends. Thetherapeutic effect of the new technique was authenticated by cl inical results, including the change of symptoms and phy sical signs, and by comparing the pre-operational Lysholm score with the post one. Results Nineteen pieces of instruments weredeveloped. All the operation were successful, with no harm to nerves and vessels. The follow-up was 6 months to 24 mo nths (mean15 months). At the last follow-up, all the symptoms disappeared, including pain, swell ing and locking, etc. The Lysholm sc oreafter 6 months of operation was 87.8 ± 9.2, showing statistically significant difference when compared with per-operati on ( P lt; 0.01). Conclusion It is feasible to suture injured menisci with the new instruments and technique. It is an effective way to repair menisci with tendon according to the short-term results.
ObjectiveTo systematically review the non-inferiority trials in the cardiovascular domain that utilize medical devices as interventions, and investigate its characteristics and threshold settings. MethodsThe PubMed, Embase, and CENTRAL databases were electronically searched to collect non-inferiority trials in the cardiovascular field involving medical devices from inception to July 26, 2023. Two reviewers independently screened literature and extracted data. The reported information included basic characteristics, features of non-inferiority trials, and threshold-setting features of the included studies. Data analysis was performed using Excel 2020 and R 4.2.1 software. ResultsA total of 214 studies were included, with 167 studies (78.0%) focusing on interventions related to coronary artery stents. The trials predominantly utilized a two-arm design (92.9%), with a prevalent use of non-inferiority absolute thresholds (96.7%) as the criteria for non-inferiority determination. In 150 studies (70.1%), non-inferiority thresholds were established based on estimated control group effect values, while 33 studies (15.4%) did not report the source of these values. The non-inferiority trial endpoint outcomes exhibited diversity, and there were substantial differences in threshold settings. The three most studied qualitative indicators were target lesion failure rates (2.1%-8.6%), target vessel failure rates (2.5%-19.6%), and major adverse cardiovascular events rates (2.1%-10.0%). Late lumen loss (0.1-0.4 mm) emerged as the most frequently studied quantitative indicator. After converting absolute non-inferiority thresholds for all indicators into relative thresholds, the range was 1.20-3.67. ConclusionSignificant variations in non-inferiority threshold settings are observed for identical endpoint outcomes across included studies, highlighting a lack of reporting on the rationale behind threshold settings.
Compared with traditional medical devices, artificial intelligence medical devices face greater challenges in the process of clinical trials due to their related characteristics of artificial intelligence technology. This paper focused on the challenges and risks in each stage of clinical trials on artificial intelligence medical devices for assisted diagnosis, and put forward corresponding coping strategies, with the aim to provide references for the performance of high-quality clinical trials on artificial intelligence medical devices and shorten the research period in China.
In recent years, the research on artificial intelligence medical devices has risen markedly along with the expanding application scenarios, exhibiting prominent interdisciplinary characteristics. From 2000 to 2024, the variety of research in artificial intelligence medical devices has significantly increased, while the balance of disciplines has slightly declined, and Simpson's diversity index has continuously increased. Medicine and biology are the main research themes and supportive disciplines in this field. Knowledge from computer science, engineering technology, and mathematics is widely involved and shows an upward trend, while content from the humanities and social sciences is less involved in the research. Compared to the United States and the United Kingdom, China has relatively less biological and chemical knowledge content in the research of this field, but more content related to computer science, engineering technology and material science is involved. This study analyzes the current state and trends of interdisciplinary on artificial intelligence medical devices from the perspective of macro-categories of disciplines, aiming to provide references for research planning, talent training and interdisciplinary cooperation in the field.
In recent years, real-world evidence data (RWD) and real-world evidence (RWE) have gained substantial attentions from healthcare practitioners and health authorities worldwide. In particular, the needs from regulatory bodies have promoted the production and use of real-world evidence. In the context of drug and device evaluation and regulation decisions, the pattern for using real world evidence may differ. This article aimed to discuss the potential uses of RWE for pre-approval clinical evaluation, post-approval monitoring and evaluation, and associated regulatory decisions, which may ultimately improve the production and use of RWE for regulatory decisions.
Real-world data is been increasingly valued nowadays. This paper combined with related requirements of clinical evaluation of medical devices in China, studied the role of real-world evidence in pre-marketing clinical evaluation of medical devices in terms of technical evaluation, in aim of providing reference for the future application of China's real-world evidence in pre-marketing clinical evaluation.
Regulatory science of medical devices serves the scientific research and regulatory activities for supervision of medical devices. Principles of science and transparency and conduction of evidence-based study, which is advocated in Evidence-based science(EBS), also apply to regulatory science of medical devices, including using evidence-based scientific tools and methods to demonstrate the safety and effectiveness, as well as quality, efficacy and cost-effectiveness of total life cycle of medical products, target customers, and scope. EBS provides both new methods and tools for regulatory science for medical devices, and provides a new basis for further scientific regulatory decisions.